I have a few old standby recipes I’ve perfected over time. This easy roasted chicken thighs with Brussels sprouts number from Cooking Light is one of them. Usually, I follow a recipe to the letter the first time to see how it runs, and I make notes about what I might change for next time. Nine out of ten times, my adjustments are related to specific quirks of my kitchen, but sometimes, there are flavor needs. This one, however, is so simple and to the point, there’s not much to change.
Instead, this will be my “tips and tricks” for getting this tasty crowd pleaser right the first time around.
Cut everything up ahead of time so it’s just a matter of moving things around. This may seem simple to a lot of you, but I watch people I know and love chop and dice and run around like beheaded chickens while also trying to watch things as they cook. Because the browning of the chicken takes some attention, I highly recommend cutting it all up ahead of time.
Use cast iron.
It’s worth the investment for something like this. I have several pans in several sizes, and if the spirit should move me one day, I’ll buy several more. There’s just a sweet satisfaction in that sear you get on food from cast iron. I don’t care what anyone says about cleaning it.
Use fresh chicken.
For some people, this is a no brainer. For many of us, though, we hit the grocery store, buy every meat type thing we need, and freeze it until it’s time to use it. I’ve done this both ways, and even with a full thaw, a previously frozen bird makes the first cooking stage more difficult than it needs to be. With frozen thighs, you get skin that sticks to the pan no matter the heat level. You end up then with broken, unbronzed, or burnt skins that you have to hide under lemon slices. Additionally, the amount of water produced by the previously frozen chicken dilutes the flavor and gives you a cast iron skillet full of oil and water when it’s time to stick it in the oven. That creates a watered down thigh that doesn’t hold up as well.
Use organic chicken.
I’m not “that person.” I do try to buy free range or grass fed meat when it’s available and my money is at a sufficient level to make this make sense. However, it’s not become a necessity (or a possibility) yet. With this and other dishes like it (where you brown the chicken), however, I’ve found it to be more amenable to the cooking techniques for a few reasons.
- The water issue mentioned above is never a problem.
- The skin separates nicely from the meat without breaking.
- The pieces cook thoroughly and tenderly without falling apart.
- You feel socially responsible when you know the chicken had a good life.
Using a high quality meat in general leads to a better outcome for any cooking technique simply because it isn’t filled with anything or treated in any way. While often times, you might not notice the difference too much when cooking at home amongst the million other things you have to do, in this case, you’ll appreciate the end result if you go up a price point on the meat. I stick with Publix GreenWise because it’s in my price range and easy to grab on a grocery run, but if you don’t have a Publix, there are a number of affordable options like these:
This is just a handful of options. Check your local stores and add them in the comments.
Be patient with the Brussels sprouts.
Yeah, this sounds silly, but I’m serious. You’ll want them to brown and crisp a bit before pouring in the broth so they’ll get that coveted crunch. You can see from the photo of the finished product above that I did not do that this time. Let me show you why.
Now. I’m no fool. I knew I’d bought very large sprouts, but two things happened. First, I got distracted mid-cooking (thanks, “real” job) and had to tend to something while the chicken was cooking and before I put these on. Secondly, I cut them into fourths because of their size and only realized afterward that I did not have a pan large enough to handle all of them. I ended up essentially stewing them in chicken broth. They were good, still crisp but not raw, but they didn’t get the opportunity to brown like they did here.
Ideally, you want to heat the pan to a rather hot temp, cook the onions like the recipe says, and then toss the sprouts in to brown and crisp. The broth step should only happen after the browning.
Mix the oil and herbs early.
Then let it sit for a while. Let it infuse. This has an awesome flavor even if you don’t do that, but I’ve found the end result is more blended if you do.
Don’t forget the lemon.
I did once. It did not work. In the second photo of the full meal above, you can see where the lemons are not cooked thoroughly. This was the time I forgot the lemon and ended up throwing it on at the last minute. The resultant sauce was good, but it didn’t have the bite it needs to make it amazing. I tried squeezing lemon into the pan with the other sauce components, but it still didn’t work properly. The key really is the cooked lemon, not just the lemon.
Also don’t skip the sauce.
Yes, skipping a butter sauce means it’s a bit healthier, but this really shines with the lemon butter sauce mixed with the herbs of the chicken. If you don’t use it, it won’t ruin the dish, but it will make it less exciting.
Try different herbs.
Then let me know how it goes. Tell me your best changes…or tell me your worst. I welcome both.
Pair it with different sides.
Also let me know what you paired it with. If you’re a grain or carb person, there are a number of options. There’s also always room for more veggies, especially some with color.